Comments on: Electronic Paper–Finally a Commercial Proposition?

By: david foster

david foster — Wed, 21 Nov 2007 19:16:36 +0000

yes, 10 ounces..I’ll fix it.

I had the same thought on link-following. Restrictions on the ability to follow links would seem to have a major impact on the kinds of content that fit well with the device.

By: Jim Rose

Jim Rose — Wed, 21 Nov 2007 18:15:54 +0000

I think it’s 10 ounces, not pounds.

Anyway, my big question is this. Sure, you can read Michelle Malkin or Instapundit for a small fee, but because of this I’m assuming that you can’t follow the links they put up. Sometimes Instapundit is nothing but links, so that would be a problem.

By: Mike Damian

Mike Damian — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 22:48:24 +0000

Discover little known elements of Chicago’s built environment.

Forgotten Chicago is a new website dedicated to documenting little known elements of Chicago’s infrastructure, architecture, neighborhoods and general cityscape, whether existing or historical.

http://www.forgottenchicago.com

By: vivictius

vivictius — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 19:33:55 +0000

The biggest problem with all the electronic books is the text available. In general you can only get fiction. So with this new Kindle you can pay ~$10 for a $4.95 paperback in electronic form. What I can not get is all my engineering texts and refrences. Having all of them in a small portable format instead of two book cases would be worth getting. That, of course, will never happen as the text book publishers make far too much money off of college students.

By: Patchitect

Patchitect — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 18:50:31 +0000

The Kindle is an interesting proposition by Amazon, and an interesting one for the e-paper display format. Dedicated e-book readers have been marketed in a number of arenas for a while with limited success, based namely on their limited application and their high price tag. The Kindle adds the wireless capabilities to a niche market, which, although admirable, is still limited. However, its a usefuill application for the e-paper format which will continue to struggle to find its consumer niche until it solves its current limitations, namely black and white only display, and low refresh rates.

However, LCD displays suffered from the same limitations 10-15 years ago, and now are becoming the standard in display technology, not only for computer applications, but also in the multimedia intensive applications that computers are quickly assuming. I would expect that this adolescent technology would have similar growing pains, and provided it continues to flirt with the edges of mainstream technology the way that it does, it will continue to mature and possibly even replace the backlit LCD technology with superior color rendition, readability and power consumption.

I look forward to the next generation of e-paper technologies, which i fully expect to be the cellphone and personal assistant type applications. Replace my PDA! i dare you!

By: Dan Croak

Dan Croak — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 18:46:11 +0000

I will be one of the first buyers of electronic paper when it *really* comes out. This device does nothing for me, however. I want electronic paper that folds, bends, and will fit in a sleeve of my suitcase or rolled up in my back pocket. I expect the first iteration to cost $300-$600 and don’t have a problem with the price tag just as I had no problem paying that amount for an iPhone, which is the latest breakthrough until Google’s GPhone comes out.

By: Tatyana

Tatyana — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 18:12:56 +0000

Aside from convenience issue, how much this folly will actually cost? Initial input – $400, then you have to pay for every book you download – yes, a tenner is not much, but the whole purpose of this thing is reading books while on the road, right? So every 4-to-5 days, while on the bus (some – on a plane) you have to to shell out $10. Plus charges for blogs (each- separately), plus charges for papers (again, separately) – it’s all piling up for way over $30 max for a regular monthly internet connection, with unlimited free reading.

Also, cellphones don’t work underground; this thing will not work in the subway!

By: Shannon Love

Shannon Love — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 17:55:50 +0000

Having used my spouses iPhone to surf the net, I don’t believe that independent devices for ebooks will ever take off. The high quality of the screen means one can read quite easily even though the text appears at first far to small. Upgrading the iPhone just slightly, perhaps with a collapsable second screen, would make it a near perfect ebook.

I think we will see the evolution of the “information” appliance i.e. a single device that serves all informational needs. We have to date used different devices to receive information like television, radio, movies, telephone, books, CD’s, computers etc because the fundamental technology of distributing and displaying the information differed for each technology and it was very difficult to

Now our informational devices are increasingly just computers in different forms all getting their information from the same packet switched network and displaying it on the same type of screens and speakers.

I suspect the final device will be pocket computer that communicates wirelessly with various small, physically disconnected interface devices. We will choose the interface based on the environment and the type of information we want to create or consume.

By: Dan from Madison

Dan from Madison — Tue, 20 Nov 2007 17:26:40 +0000

It is interesting technology. The $400 price tag seems steep, and you would think that Amazon would try to lower the price point just to get these into people’s hands.

I only read my local paper, and glossing over the dead tree takes only a few minutes for me. The rest of my news comes from the web already.

I am an avid reader and fear that I may never get through the stack of books I already have in my basement. If I ever do, I may be interested in this technology as I read in bed a lot and at times if I am reading a large tome it fatigues my arms. It will take a while for Amazon to have many of the older titles available on this medium, I would assume. That is fine with me since I also assume that the initial price of the machine will go down too.