UPDATE #2: The western bloc is growing while the Atlantic bloc stagnates.
Venezuela, Brazil and Argentina are languishing in differing shades of turmoil, steadily losing ground to regional underdogs. The Pacific Alliance, an historic trade agreement between Mexico, Peru, Chile, and Colombia (and coming soon: Costa Rica), has the potential to recolor Latin America’s economic map and introduce some new regional powerhouses to the world stage.
Four nations are developing an initiative that could add new dynamism to Latin America, redraw the economic map of the region, and boost its connections with the rest of the world—especially Asia. It could also offer neighboring countries a pragmatic alternative to the more political groupings dominated by Brazil, Cuba, and Venezuela.
UPDATE: More on the role Cuba is playing in Venezuela now.
Belmont Club has a good post today on the collapse of Venezuela. The car manufacturers have announced they are closing their plants.
Toyota Motor Co. said it would shut down its assembly operations in Venezuela due to the government’s foreign exchange controls that have crippled imports and made it impossible to bring in parts needed to build its vehicles.
The country’s other car manufacturers, including General Motors and Ford, haven’t even started operations this year, while waiting for needed parts to arrive.
The oil field workers left years ago when the Chavez government cut oil workers’ pay.
Workers’ protests continue at Venezuela’s Puerto La Cruz refinery, in the northeastern state of Anzoátegui. The oil workers are requesting the payment of their contractual benefits. Workers gathered and had some meetings in the refinery and handed out fliers. These actions will continue until the authorities of state-run oil company Petróleos de Venezuela (Pdvsa) meet each of their requests. Oil workers complained that the oil industry has violated 80% of the current collective bargaining agreement.
Army officers had no such limit on pay raises.
[They] got a 40 % raise last year. So let’s see, they get a 40 % raise in 2010, and a 50 % raise in 2011, and meanwhile oil field workers, the ones who create the wealth the government uses to give these obscene pay raises to the military, are protesting low pay and lack of legal payments they are supposed to get.
‘Brazil is becoming Argentina, Argentina is becoming Venezuela, and Venezuela is becoming Zimbabwe’
The oil workers who could, all left for Canada. That was about the time that the Alberta oil sands fields were coming on line. Those workers, and especially the engineers, are not going back to Venezuela any time soon.
Welcome to Hugo Chavez’s Venezuela, a country with the fifth largest oil reserves in the world and absolutely broke. It’s a remarkable achievement for Chavismo. A just-wow moment. Socialism is useless at everything except for smashing things in record time. There it excels. It’s hard to imagine that as late as the 1980s Venezuela had the highest standard of living in Latin America. But then in 1960 Detroit was the richest city in the world in per capita income. Now it’s well … Detroit.
Cuba is helping the post-Chavez government to cope.
The violence against unarmed citizens is reminiscent of the April 11, 2002, bloodletting, when 17 individuals who were part of a peaceful opposition march in the streets of Caracas were similarly gunned down by snipers. That was the day the head of the military told Hugo Chávez that he would not move against the crowd and that he was removing Chávez from office. Chávez prevailed, in part due to U.S. dogma against “a coup” and in part because the opposition bungled what ought to have been a transition to democracy.
Obama is a friend of Venezuela and will oppose any attempt to overturn the tyranny. He showed his true colors in El Salvador by rewarding the bad behavior of the current government.
What we see today in El Salvador is a government heading in the opposite direction from those core principles. In 2000, El Salvador was ranked as the 11th-freest economy in the world, according to the annual Index of Economic Freedom co-published by The Heritage Foundation and The Wall Street Journal. Today, it is 53rd and has registered declining scores in six of the 10 economic freedoms, including investment freedom, the management of public spending, labor freedom, and freedom from corruption. El Salvador’s performance in other world economic indices has also plummeted.
Obama’s friends seem to have dodgy records on civil liberties.
The deterioration in central and south America continues apace . There is an interesting pattern.
‘There are two Latin Americas right now. The first is a bloc of countries—including Brazil, Argentina and Venezuela—that faces the Atlantic Ocean, mistrusts globalization and gives the state a large role in the economy. The second—made up of countries that face the Pacific such as Mexico, Peru, Chile and Colombia—embraces free trade and free markets.’
The results are becoming clear.
Stifling bureaucracy, protectionist trade barriers, widespread corruption, lack of investment in infrastructure and the limited scope of economic reforms have been piling up like wood on a bonfire for a number of years. Inflation and weak government finances have provided the starter fluid and it maybe that lower demand for commodities will be the spark.
The divide has been developing for years. As Luhnow reports, ‘ A key moment in creating the two Latin Americas came in 2005, when Brazil, Argentina and Venezuela (then led by Mr. Chávez) lined up to kill the proposed Free Trade Area of the Americas—a free-trade zone stretching from Alaska to Patagonia and promoted by President George W. Bush. Troubled by the FTAA’s demise, the Pacific Alliance set out to create its own free-trade area, eliminating tariffs on 90% of goods and setting a timetable to eliminate the rest.’
Obama seems more interested in the Atlantic states.
The genius of the Left — Chavez’s for example — is that it destroys things from the inside out. They pervert religion, collapse the mores, abolish the family, shred the constitution and gradually expropriate the property. The differences from one day to the next are apparently imperceptible, but it is harder and harder to go back until finally there is no reversal of ‘progressive gains’ possible at all. The public is finally faced with the stark choice between chaos or authoritarianism. And most people will chose the Boss over the Mob.
Does any of that sound familiar ?
Most people are spurred into resistance by a crisis. But they remain lulled into complacency while the crisis remains imperceptible. Progressive tyranny benefits from image management, and takes great pains to keep crisis from view. The most insidious thing about a secret police is its very secrecy, because the mayhem it wreaks is upon the intangibles, among things we call legitimacy. So it goes until only a facade is left. Until the day of death the victim is largely asymptomatic, except for a gradual weakening. When the onset comes he discovers that his immune system is completely gone and the end is sudden.
And Iran is allying itself with Venezuela.
20 thoughts on “Is Venezuela Collapsing ?”
That told me how bad things are when Cuba is supporting Venezuela. The Soviets did the same thing with mining – Herbert Hoover had built this very profitable and efficient facility in the Ukraine, and the Bolsheviks ruined it.
Bill, have you seen Michael Totten’s series on Cuba? It starts here.
You guys are pretentious, pompous punks at your worst. If I may be unnecessarily alliterative.
So, Venezuela is thriving ?
I guess Ken was just driving by.
“Cuba is helping the post-Chavez government to cope.” A glimmer of gallows humour in a grim piece. Why do people keep trying socialism when its failure is entirely predictable?
Nah Mike, he’s just another xocialist idiot troll trying to muddy the water.
If we’re punks, then you’ve been punked.
” In both countries a lot of noise has been made and the western presstitutes have spread heaps of propaganda – but in actual reality not that much has happened or changed.”
So, Venezuela is thriving. That’s what I asked. Communism works ! All those stories about the Gulag were not true.
Got it ! Thanks
Ken is right. Any day now the Glorious Revolution will succeed in Venezuela & Cuba. They’ll have meat and grain and good beer, and efficient cars and comfortable homes, short work weeks, and peaceful cities, and they’ll be exporting shiploads of goods throughout the world! You’ll see. You just have to Believe. And follow what Dear Leader tells you. You’ll see. Any day now….
Meanwhile, in The Real World, you’ll be shot in Cuba if you’re caught eating meat, that’s reserved for the Ruling Class. It’s a Workers Paradise.
“Meanwhile, in The Real World, you’ll be shot in Cuba if you’re caught eating meat, that’s reserved for the Ruling Class. It’s a Workers Paradise.”
Michael Totten has a good series on Cuba where he visited last fall. It seems to be unavailable at the moment or I would link to it.
Cuba didn’t kill a million Iraqis and there was no Cuban equivalent of Madeleine Korben “Albright” saying “it’s worth it” (cause they’re not Ashkenazis.)
Ken, the Americans didn’t “kill a million Iraqis” either. The al Qeada in Iraq folks killed quite a few. The Iranians killed a lot. Iraqis killed a lot.
You need to put down the communist book you are reading and step away slowly so you don’t hurt yourself.
Oh, Ken, I hope you post another link to read.
They count on people not actually knowing anything about the world, or about history, or about anything else, to succeed with their propaganda. The minute you point out their stories don’t match the facts they change the subject.
>>Michael Totten has a good series on Cuba where he visited last fall. It seems to be unavailable at the moment or I would link to it.
Michael, I read it. Strange place, that Cuba. Like a tropical paradise in hell.
I was going to comment that people need to make better argument against socialism than shut up, because Cuba- and explain from there.
But no need, because I clicked on one of your links.
You made the argument for me- and the idiocy displayed needs to disseminated far and wide.
If you think Venezuela is doing swimmingly, except for damage done by those wreckers who somehow always show up under socialist regimes, then you’re just a fool.
Find and read that Michael Totten series about Cuba, for example.
It has pictures, if I recall. That may help.
About 20 years ago a friend of mine in the power industry worked for a while in Venezuela. He said it was a beautiful country with some of the prettiest women he’d ever seen.
They had oil, agriculture and other resources.
Unfortunately it wasn’t particularly well run under the right and absolutely destroyed by the left. They have driven out the technocrats, implemented crazy re-distributionist policies, and let society and law and order collapse.
This is a very sad story and I feel sorry for those in that country just trying to make a living and build a better life for their families.
The current regime can’t last much longer. Chavez had charisma at least along with the help of the Cubans but the new guy is just a stone clown and it won’t be long before it all collapses.
Unfortunately I have no idea what comes next.
Carl, I worked with an engineer from Venenzuela at a nuclear plant who said the same thing. He left in the early 80’s because of the corruption from the current regime then, and the rest of his family left not long after Chavez came into power.
With the impending collapse of Venenzuela, along with Cuba this will make two festering sores of socialist failure on the Western Hemisphere, with Argentina occupying the on deck spot as they have for 50 years.
Comments are closed.