Chicago Boyz

                 
 
 
What Are Chicago Boyz Readers Reading?
 

 
  •   Enter your email to be notified of new posts:
  •   Problem? Question?
  •   Contact Authors:

  • CB Twitter Feed
  • Blog Posts (RSS 2.0)
  • Blog Posts (Atom 0.3)
  • Incoming Links
  • Recent Comments

    • Loading...
  • Authors

  • Notable Discussions

  • Recent Posts

  • Blogroll

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • If Obama Ruled China

    Posted by David Foster on March 16th, 2011 (All posts by )

    NYT, via Phineas at Sister Toldjah:

    Mr. Obama has told people that it would be so much easier to be the president of China. As one official put it, “No one is scrutinizing Hu Jintao’s words in Tahrir Square.”

    What might possess an American president to tell people that it would be easier to be president of China? Some possibilities…

    For one thing, Obama is clearly much more interested in domestic policy than in foreign policy. He views it as his mission to reconstruct American society in ways that are more to his liking, and considers the need to deal with other countries to be an irritating distraction.

    Another factor is that people often view other people’s jobs as being easier than their own–see the old children’s story about the farmer and his wife for an example. This is particularly true, it would seem, of people who are constitutionally of a jealous nature, who devote much of their mental energy to the suspicion that someone else has it better. Barack Obama seems to me to be of this ilk: there is no possible position in life he could assume that would overcome his feelings of jealousy and resentment toward others. His comment during the campaign about bitter clingers sounds like pure projection.

    What if Obama really did become the leader of China? Would he actually find the job easier than his present one?

    If Obama suddenly became leader of China, with all of Hu Jintao’s powers, I feel certain that he would reduce that country to utter chaos within 5 years. China has many problems of which Obama, with his focus on surface appearances, is probably unaware (see for instance this post)…in addition, China lacks much of the wealth, positive institutional inertia and strength of civil society from which the US benefits (and which will hopefully allow us to survive Obama’s leadership for a few years). While China’s economy is not nearly as centralized as it once was, the government does play a more directive role than it does in the US, which means it has more opportunity to very rapidly screw things up. This kind of system also puts more stress on the man at the helm, an important consideration for “leaders” who are highly focused on reducing their own stress levels and maximizing their golfing time.

    Things like the “green energy” obsession and ethanol subsidies can be endured by a rich country, at least for a limited period of time. Obama’s methods in China would result in widespread starvation and civil war, and I don’t think it would take very long.

    Nor would an Obama regime in China be likely to do anything to improve the status of democracy and civil liberties in that country…Obama has shown minimal interest in support for democratization abroad, and at home his orientation toward centralized control of all aspects of life is quite clear, as is his tolerance for intimidation tactics such as those engaged in by the New Black Panther Party in the Philadelphia voter-intimidation case and by various union-affiliated thugs in the recent Wisconsin events.

    No, Mr Obama, you would not find Hu Jintao’s job easier than your present one. But your assumption of that position would be even harder on the people of China than it would on you.

     

    10 Responses to “If Obama Ruled China”

    1. Robert Schwartz Says:

      It is the fantasy of parlor pinks like Obama and Tom Friedman, that in an autocracy, particularly China, when the autocrat articulates a desire, no matter how slight, everyone under his rule leaps to do his bidding.

      The truth is this fantasy tells you more about the fantasists, than it does about the world. In fact, autocrats, just like democratically elected officers of lawful governments, must provide incentives (either positive or negative) for others to implement their commands. Where autocrats in lawless societies have it easier is their access to violence. A few thugs can solve a lot of problems cheaply and easily. Where the officers of a law abiding society have it easier is that most citizens obey the law because they want to.

    2. Andrew X Says:

      Yeah, while everyone harped on the appalling authoritarian and self-pitying nature of that comment, possibly rightly so, I was always struck (but not surprised *sigh* ), by it’s patent blindness and obliviousness to the reasons why trying to run China would be no picnic.

      I guess I could eleborate on Chinese finances being considered highly dubious by many, on the sheer mount of poverty still there, social and racial unrest, that many considered observers wonder if the country may still fly to pieces at some point….

      But why do the details really matter? The statement is an American President simultaneously expressing a desire for authoritarian rule, a whiny self-pity that he is forced, poor dear, to govern without such untramelled powers, and an embarrasing expression of ignorance of the very nation he is speaking of at the moment (not to mention his own). Truly a gem on multiple levels.

    3. Vlad Konings Says:

      In China they play for keeps. If I were the leader of China, I’d constantly fear for my life.

      I suspect Obama is thinking that, if he were the leader of China, his political opponents would constantly fear for their lives.

    4. David Foster Says:

      See also: Obama the Scrivener.

      (As a side note, I wonder how many of the “progressives” who talk endlessly about their intellectual superiority actually know who Bartleby the Scrivner was…)

    5. bgates Says:

      If I were the leader of China, I’d constantly fear for my life.

      Yep. And if Obama were the leader of China, he wouldn’t last a week.

    6. Steve Korn Says:

      Marvelous, Dave.

      It is these unscripted statements that reveal the true nature of our president.

      The remaking of America would proceed so much quicker if not for those pesky Congress people representing people who don’t know any better

    7. David Foster Says:

      Good to see you here, Steve!

    8. tehag Says:

      Obama is like FDR, whose friendship with Uncle Joe went beyond admiration. FDR and his advisors admired Uncle Joe and Uncle Benito. Their ideas of proper government, with which they infected America, have come to fruition.

    9. Phil Says:

      The first time he turned in a multi-trillion-dollar deficit Obama would find himself fired from being President of China and suddenly presiding over a rice paddy somewhere in distant Xinjiang.

      (Yes, they’d truck in the water for the rice paddy just for him).

    10. likwidshoe Says:

      They don’t lead in China. They rule.