Chicago Boyz

What Are Chicago Boyz Readers Reading?

  •   Enter your email to be notified of new posts:
  •   Problem? Question?
  •   Contact Authors:

  • Blog Posts (RSS 2.0)
  • Blog Posts (Atom 0.3)
  • Incoming Links
  • Recent Comments

    • Loading...
  • Authors

  • Notable Discussions

  • Recent Posts

  • Blogroll

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • “Democracy, Immigration, Multiculturalism — Pick Any Two”

    Posted by Jonathan on December 16th, 2005 (All posts by )

    Jim Bennett posts some characteristically insightful thoughts on assimilation. I hope that his tag line catches on.

    UPDATE: Commenter Brock credits the title phrase to Wretchard of The Belmont Club.

    UPDATE2: Jim Bennett says he came up with the phrase on his own and has been using it since around 2001, which is before The Belmont Club existed as a blog. My search of Belmont Club’s last two sites turned up no instances of the phrase, but it’s possible that I didn’t search competently. It’s also possible that Wretchard came up with the phrase independently or that he read it first in one of Jim’s pieces. Either way, it’s a great line.


    5 Responses to ““Democracy, Immigration, Multiculturalism — Pick Any Two””

    1. Brock Says:

      The tagline is from Wretchard at Belmont Club, actually.

      Just want to make sure he get’s the credit. It’s a great line, and I hope it catches on too.

    2. Jim Bennett Says:

      I admire Wretchard and Belmont Club, and don’t doubt that he has used that line. But when I used it first in my UPI column (and without checking, I think I’ve been using it since 2001 or thereabouts) I coined it myself. I’m not sure Belmont Club has been going that long; the first blog I ever say was Instapundit, and that was like August 2001 — I think I used the phrase before that. It’s a fairly simple construction on the template of the common engineering phrase “fast, cheap, or good — pick any two.” That was said all the time at American Rocket Company, and probably anywhere that engineers work.

      Is there a first cite on Belmont Club’s use of the phrase?

    3. Brock Says:

      Terribly sorry for the mix-up. I did see it first at Belmont Club and thought that is was such a great line that I surely would have seen it passed around the blogs. Perhaps Wretchard did get it from Mr. Bennet, but I can’t say for sure.

      Also can’t find the post he said it in either, which is odd since I could have sworn it was only a couple days ago. Ah well, maybe I’m just losing my mind :-) Like I said, sorry for the confusion.

    4. Jonathan Says:

      Not to worry. One of the nice things about blogging is the ease of making corrections.

    5. Jim Bennett Says:

      No problem. I considered it a meme I released into the wild a long time ago. I’m glad it’s propogating. But it’s always nice to keep the record straight, even in minor things.