Chicago Boyz

What Are Chicago Boyz Readers Reading?

  •   Enter your email to be notified of new posts:
  •   Problem? Question?
  •   Contact Authors:

  • Blog Posts (RSS 2.0)
  • Blog Posts (Atom 0.3)
  • Incoming Links
  • Recent Comments

    • Loading...
  • Authors

  • Notable Discussions

  • Recent Posts

  • Blogroll

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Investment Journal Update

    Posted by In-Cog-Nito on May 8th, 2004 (All posts by )

    Here are the latest efforts in the In-Cog-Nito Needs Money Fund.

    Ameritrade sucks, don’t use them. They may be fine once you get up and running, but the initial process to get up and running is too slow for my taste. The main complaint I have is that they won’t let you short stocks without the funds clearing. And with ACH transfers (they claim it’s fast in their ads), it takes a good five days for the funds to settle. Starting without the ability to short in this market is like boxing with one hand tied behind your back; it takes away half your arsenal. Their interface is also too cluttered for my taste. I was a huge fan of Datek when I first started: clean web interface, excellent value in terms of commission costs and margin interest, fast and responsive customer service. Ameritrade bought Datek a few years ago. I tried also going the route of re-opening my old Datek account. It was nice to see my old trading history still preserved there – a stroll down memory lane. Other than that, being a part of Ameritrade, their customer service seemed to have gone down hill as well. Obviously, I’m a more demanding user than your average investor, but it never hurts to have the best available tools at your disposal eh? So learn from my first mistake, don’t go with Ameritrade.

    I opened an account with Scottrade today, and so far so good. They remind me of what Datek was about five years ago. Clean interface. Good fast service. Super easy forms they have the shortest options form I have seen of any brokerage (1 page). Their web interface is something else. Technology and competition have really upped the ante in what is available to the general public in terms of information, execution, and trading tools. One nice bonus is that you get free Dow Jones real time news. Its not really that important for most investing purposes unless you day trade, but its nice to have nonetheless. Seven bucks a trade and relatively low margin rates are more pluses.

    The positive of not getting up and running fast is that its a week off to get up to speed on the feel of the market. Ive set up a free trial subscription to part of Jim Cramers It was my go-to site for news when I first started. They still put out good articles, but Cramer seems to have lost some of his luster i.e. his performance isnt that good now, based on his Action Alert Portfolio. My biggest thing is that Nortel (NT) makes up about 6% of his portfolio. It seems Nortels comeback was based on accounting shenanigans. I remember one of Cramers constant sayings years ago was that he kept a post-it on his screen saying accounting troubles = sell. Seems he is not keeping to his own advice, and its hurting him. Scott Moritz over there is still putting out good articles, primarily because he seems to be a natural skeptic, or at least he writes with a healthy dose of skepticism something you always want in the market. One thing I really dont like about now is that they try to nickel and dime you on all their services. If you want to read articles from so and so, you have to pay this much each month. Its good for their business obviously, especially if the writer has built up a loyal audience. But its quite a sticker shock for new investors. The best thing I liked about them back then was that a newbie can get strong opinions, and everything they had to offer about the market for twenty or thirty bucks a month. An excellent value proposition. But if you want everything now, its going to cost ya.

    So what to do? One thing I liked back then was the Yahoo message boards on stocks. Theyre easily available and are strong opinions for free. Most of it is garbage, but I like to think of them as pre-cursors to blogging. People literally write whatever theyre thinking, and if you take it on the merits of their arguments backed up by facts and links to relevant articles, its useful. The main thing, as with all news, is you have to pick up the ability to filter out the good, and toss the bad. Don’t get me wrong, message boards shouldn’t be your main source of information. But there’s more than one way to look at it.

    A couple of stock specific thoughts: VIP and MBT are getting hammered. Their charts arent too pretty. I would let it play itself out before going long on these two.

    BOBJ (I pronounce it Bob-Jay): Ive been itching to short this one. Their being a French company is reason enough. But the chart aint too pretty, and it looks like theyre starting to have some accounting problems. Theyre a business software firm, and from what I know, software firms tend to be aggressive in their revenue recognition to boost sales. BOBJ has close to 80% gross margins, but only 1% of their revenues make it to their bottom line. This says to me theres a lot of waste going on. The SEC has an informal probe with regards to their deferred revenue, or backlog. It wont be a fast short, but itll be interesting to see how it plays out. Im guessing if theres smoke, theres a fire somewhere.



    8 Responses to “Investment Journal Update”

    1. Lex Says:

      Nito, this is good stuff. One non-substantive comment. I’d edit it so at least the first paragraph is on the front of the blog. I think more people will read it that way, and it deserves to be widely read.

    2. Andy B Says:

      Check out the Cool Cat Report at . I know, it’s a silly name, but my friend is the editor (he named it after a character in one of his daughter’s school plays) and it is for real. No Goldman Sachs number-crunching, just technical analysis of small-cap stocks to TRADE, not invest in. Track record is great, and it’s legit. Let me know if you like it, and I’m sure he’ll swing you a comped subscription, you know, for the cause. ;/

    3. in-cog-nito Says:


      Glad you liked it. I’ll edit it to add the first paragraph.

      Andy B,

      Phenomenal returns for Cool Cat. I like the name too. Thanks for the tip, I’ll check it out.

    4. David Mercer Says:

      Have you looked at Scotrade? Haven’t used them, but they have really good prices and 3rd party trade speed ratings. Haven’t used any broker, as I’ve never had enough to spare!

      As always, read options agreements for short allocation and suchnot; I don’t know what the norms are, but terms may differ!

    5. in-cog-nito Says:


      Thanks for the tip, funny you should mention Scottrade… = ) I opened an account with them on Friday. I think you read only the first part of the post. I’ll edit the post to show more. There is good stuff other people posted that I didn’t want to “crowd out” with a long post.

    6. David Mercer Says:

      Oy vey, in hindsight I did indeed not read all of it; must have missed a ‘more’ link or something!

      Aside from a few commercials when randomly channel surfin onto CNBC, I’d first heard anything about scottrade in an investment community on livejournal. They had horror stories about most of the other online brokers recently, and rated scottrade tops on service, speed and price.

      Of course down the road who knows which’ll be the next greatest one, but they look like the sweet spot for now!

    7. Richard A. Heddleson Says:

      Thanks for the expansion.

    8. Girish Maiya Says:

      Take a look at this from Mark Cuban. He basically says that people with small amounts of capital just shouldn’t invest in the stock market – he doesn’t really provide an alternative though…